
PRECISION
for Writers and EditorsAutumn 1999
Precision master list
Go to 
© 1999 Analytic Services
|
Writing to CommunicateWriting is for communication. This is no less true of technical writing than of writing for newspapers, magazines, or books of fiction. Except perhaps for a few novelists or poets, we do not write solely to express ourselves; we write to say what we have to say, so that our audience can understand it.The writers biggest job is that of combining wordsand often numbers and graphicsto share ideas. Organizing the material and choosing precisely the right words require more effort than just writing down what is in the writers head. The knowledgeable writer possesses information the reader does not
The Editors JobThe editors job is to assist the writer in the task of communication. Writing should be so clear to the reader the first time its read, says editor Margaret Palm, who teaches communication seminars through her company, WorkLink, that the reader should never have to go back and read something twice to understand it.If something can be read two ways, somebody somewhere will read it the wrong way. A cooler is not a large system impact stated one document we edited. We queried the author: Does this mean a cooler would not have a large impact on the system or a cooler does not have an impact on large systems? The reader might have read it only one way, or not understood it at all. The editor looks for things that are perfectly clear to the writer but not clear to others, and makes sure that the writer will be understood.
Care About the ReaderI dont care about grammar, a writer told us when he brought his article in for editing. In fact it seemed that the writer, like many others, didnt care about a lot of things. This merger does not seems to posse any intimate security risks to the United States was one statement in the article. We called out the posse of language deputies; we changed posse to pose and fixed dozens more errors, grammar and otherwise. We had to query the author to find out what intimate was supposed to be (hed meant to use immediate).Unfortunately, this writer was not alone. Not in making mistakeswe all make thosebut in not caring.
If you dont care about grammar, at least care about the reader. If you have something worth saying, care about communicating it.
Richard Mitchell, Less Than Words Can Say (Boston: Little, Brown, 1979)
Other Uses of the SpellcheckerBesides pausing at every misspelled word, the spellchecker pauses at every unknown proper name and abbreviation. Turn this to your advantage. When it stops at a proper name, if youre sure its spelled correctly, click on Ignore All. Then watch for different versions of the same name. This procedure has saved me countless times, spotting, for example, (Senator) Arlen Spector after Id verified that Specter was correct. The spellchecker can also find abbreviations used only once or twice. The first time it comes to an unknown term, such as MDR (medium data rate), I click Ignore and make a note of it. If it appears three times or more, I click Ignore All. Otherwise I spell it out in the one or two places the spellchecker found it. This technique wont work if you add those abbreviations to your personal dictionary.
Steve Dunham ![]() Slash the Slash!The most abused punctuation mark? For our money (paltry though that may be), its the slash. According to Words Into Type, the slash has a few standard uses: in fractions, or as a sign for shillings, or to indicate line breaks in bibliographical matter or poetry. Also, between and and or it means or.In the hands of many technical writers, however, the slash is treated like a utility conjunction. Here is an example from an Air Force document, New World Vistas:
Information and Space will become inextricably entwined. The Information/ Space milieu will interact strongly with the air and groundWhat does that slash signify? Clearly this is not poetry (though that space after the slash might suggest it), nor are Information and Space numerator and denominator. Nor could the slash mean orthe milieu involves information and space, inextricably entwined. The slash seems to mean and, or maybe plus, or combined with. Another example from that same document: human/machine interface. Again the slash seems to indicate not alternatives but a joining or meeting. Ordinarily a hyphen would be used: human-machine interface.
If writers are looking for a punctuation mark that means inextricably entwined, like the snakes on the caduceus, maybe they could try the section mark, and write, The Information§Space milieu, and, human§machine interface. Initially RedundantThe automated teller machine machine and the personal identification number number are two common redundancies spawned by electronic banking. Almost every day you hear (or worse, read) about an ATM machine or a PIN number. (Publishing has its equivalent, the ISBN number, or International Standard Book Number number.)The multitude of capital letters substituting for words nowadays has created an explosion of redundancies because writers couple the shortened versions to words without thinking about the meaning. Its dismaying to find even Tom Clancy, the preeminent technical writer of fiction, repeatedly referring to HARM missiles in his book Carrier (HARM missiles are High-Speed Anti-Radiation Missile missiles). Elsewhere, we have the GPS system (the Global Positioning System system), the IC community (the Intelligence Community community), LEA agencies (law enforcement agency agencies), and a whopper of a redundancy, the GLONASS satellite navigation system (the Global Navigation Satellite System satellite navigation system).
It seems that many writers are not only forgetting the literal meanings of ordinary words (such as arenasee how often hippodrome could be substituted for arena when that word is used as, supposedly, a metaphor) but forgetting the literal meanings of the abbreviations they bandy about. Instead of giving precise meaning in a small space, they add words without adding meaningand thats a failure to communicate. Editorial AssistancePlain LanguageThe Plain Language Action Network has produced a catalog of writing sins and their corresponding virtues in Writing User-Friendly Documents. The 45-page manual is a compendium of basic writing principlesprinciples often ignored, especially in technical and government writing:
Tom Clancy, Marine (New York: Berkley Books, 1996) |
Precision is published by ANSER, a nonprofit public-service research institute.
Editors: Steve Dunham, Noëlle MacKenzie, Julie Wright.
Send correspondence, complaints, questions, and compliments to stephen.dunham@anser.org.
ANSER
2900 S. Quincy St., Suite 800
Arlington, VA 22206
703.416.2000
www.anser.org
Copyright 1999 Analytic Services Inc. The contents may be reproduced as long as credit is given to the source: Copyright 1999 Analytic Services. Used by permission.